
2025Daumilas Ardickas, Urtis Šulinskas
Mainly reviews and how-to-play. A Carnivore Did It! is covered on BoardGameVideo.com by 3 reviews, 3 how-to-play guides, 3 recorded sessions, and 1 other video.
From BoardGameGeek
A Carnivore Did It! promises a guilty meat-eater, but you will have to determine the culprit for yourself. Maybe an herbivore was actually behind the crime, or perhaps you're searching for two culprits - or even three? For each case in this co-operative game, you're given a number of suspects, with each suspect being assigned a statement, e.g., "Shark is telling the truth" or "A carnivore did it". You know how many culprits you're looking for, and you have some idea of how truthful everyone is being. Perhaps only one suspect is lying, or perhaps 3-4 of them are telling the truth. Putting all of this information together, can you determine who did the crime? A Carnivore Did It! includes two thousand cases, each with a single solution, with the difficulty increasing to have up to seven suspects, conditional statements, and varying levels of truthiness. Also included is a campaign mode that links several cases together, with you scoring in them based on the amount of time it takes to find each solution...if you find them at all.
A Carnivore Did It! has 10 videos from 8 creators: 3 reviews, 3 how-to-play guides, 3 playthroughs and 1 other video. They date from 2025 to May 2026.
To learn the rules, start with "All the Games with Steph: A Carnivore Did It! - Teach & Playthrough" by Steph Hodge, which runs 26 min. For a quicker teach, "A Carnivore Did It - How to Play - Boardgame Ninja - Explainer" by BoardgameNinja runs 6 min.
For an opinion before you buy, start with "A Carnivore Did It! Review: Steak Your Claim" by The Dice Tower. 3 creators have reviewed it. To see it played, watch "A CARNIVORE DID IT! | Cases 1,2 & 3 | Learn While Playing" by Jucchee, one of 3 playthroughs.
If you like it, try Planet, Message in a Bottle, Captain Obvious and Hedgehog Roll, also by Urtis Šulinskas.
2024Urtis Šulinskas
2 - 6 players10 - 15 minLight weight
2024Urtis Šulinskas
3 - 10 players30 - 60 minLight weight
From BoardGameGeek:
A Carnivore Did It! promises a guilty meat-eater, but you will have to determine the culprit for yourself. Maybe an herbivore was actually behind the crime, or perhaps you're searching for two culprits - or even three? For each case in this co-operative game, you're given a number of suspects, with each suspect being assigned a statement, e.g., "Shark is telling the truth" or "A carnivore did it". You know how many culprits you're looking for, and you have some idea of how truthful everyone is being. Perhaps only one suspect is lying, or perhaps 3-4 of them are telling the truth. Putting all of this information together, can you determine who did the crime? A Carnivore Did It! includes two thousand cases, each with a single solution, with the difficulty increasing to have up to seven suspects, conditional statements, and varying levels of truthiness. Also included is a campaign mode that links several cases together, with you scoring in them based on the amount of time it takes to find each solution...if you find them at all.
Designers
Daumilas Ardickas, Urtis Šulinskas
Artist
Cecilia Lonnie
Publisher
Horrible Guild
Categories